BBQ Blog
Pros And Cons Of Gas And Charcoal BBQ’s And Best Buys In UK And USA
Gas vs Charcoal BBQs: Which Grill Wins the Flame War?
Choosing between gas and charcoal BBQs can feel like taking sides in a classic culinary showdown. It’s not just about cooking—it’s about the experience. Each grill type brings something unique to the table, and knowing their individual strengths (and drawbacks) is key to choosing the BBQ that suits your style.
Whether you’re a weekend warrior or a seasoned grill master, understanding the pros and cons of each will help you sizzle your way to barbecue greatness.
Gas BBQs: Convenience, Control, and Clean-Up Ease
Gas BBQs are the go-to choice for quick, no-fuss grilling. With just the turn of a knob, you’re fired up and ready to cook. Perfect for spontaneous get-togethers or weeknight dinners, gas grills bring the heat fast—and with impressive precision.
Pros of Gas BBQs:
- Instant Ignition: Forget fumbling with matches or waiting for coals to catch—just turn on the gas, and you’re cooking in minutes.
- Temperature Control: Adjust heat easily with knobs for perfect results every time—especially handy when cooking multiple items.
- Minimal Mess: No ash, no charcoal dust. Clean-up is usually as simple as brushing off the grates.
- Consistent Cooking: Gas burners provide even heat distribution across the grill.
Cons of Gas BBQs:
- Higher Initial Cost: Quality gas grills can come with a bigger price tag compared to their charcoal counterparts.
- Propane Dependency: You’ll need to keep gas canisters on hand or have a natural gas line installed.
- Less Smoky Flavour: While convenient, gas grills can lack that deep, smoky taste that charcoal fans crave.
Charcoal BBQs: Flavour, Heat, and Traditional Charm
Charcoal BBQs are all about embracing the art of slow and smoky cooking. They may take longer to prep, but many grill purists argue that the rich flavour payoff is unbeatable.
Pros of Charcoal BBQs:
- Authentic BBQ Flavour: That unmistakable smoky taste is what makes charcoal grilling a favourite for foodies and traditionalists.
- High Heat Searing: Ideal for getting a restaurant-quality char on steaks and burgers.
- Affordable Options: Many charcoal grills are budget-friendly, making them a great entry point for beginners.
Cons of Charcoal BBQs:
- Longer Setup Time: Lighting coals and waiting for them to heat up takes patience and practice.
- Messy Clean-Up: Ashes and charcoal residue require more post-BBQ elbow grease.
- Less Temperature Control: Adjusting heat often means shifting coals or opening vents—more art than science.
Health and Safety: A Quick Note
When it comes to health, gas BBQs may have a slight edge. Gas burns cleaner than charcoal, producing fewer airborne pollutants and potentially fewer carcinogens. That said, any grilling method requires care to avoid flare-ups and over-charring your food.
Pro tip: No matter your grill of choice, prioritize food safety, use quality tools, and keep your grill clean to reduce health risks.
Which BBQ Is Right for You?
The best BBQ isn’t necessarily the fanciest or the most traditional—it’s the one that fits your lifestyle.
- Love entertaining with minimal prep? Go gas.
- Crave bold, smoky flavour and enjoy the ritual? Charcoal’s calling your name.
- Tight on time during the week, but want the real-deal BBQ on weekends? Why not both?
If you’ve got the space and budget, many BBQ lovers opt for a dual grill setup—gas for quick cooks, and charcoal for flavour-packed feasts.
Top BBQ Picks for the UK & USA (2023 Edition)
Here’s a roundup of standout grills, whether you’re based in the UK or the USA. These models are well-reviewed and offer great value for their respective price ranges.
Best Gas BBQs:
UK
- Weber Spirit II E-310 – Reliable, user-friendly, and offers fantastic grilling performance.
- Fuego Element – Compact, modern design with solid heat distribution.
USA
- Weber Genesis II E-315 – Excellent build quality, fast heat-up, and precise temp control.
- Napoleon Rogue 425 – Stylish and powerful, with extra cooking space for big gatherings.
Best Charcoal BBQs:
UK
- Landmann Tristar – Durable and spacious, ideal for larger BBQ parties.
- Big Green Egg – Iconic ceramic grill offering amazing heat retention and versatility.
USA
- Kamado Joe Classic II – The ultimate in charcoal grilling, with tight temperature control and premium features.
- Weber Original Kettle Premium – A beloved classic with a timeless design and great performance.
Final Thoughts: Flame On, Your Way
When it comes to gas vs. charcoal BBQs, there’s no wrong answer—only the one that fits your tastes and lifestyle. Whether you’re craving quick weeknight burgers or long, slow-smoked ribs, the right grill will turn every meal into a celebration.
So… are you Team Gas or Team Charcoal? Whichever you choose, you’re just a spark away from grilling greatness
Just so you know: some links in this post are affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission – at no extra cost to you. It helps us keep bringing you honest reviews, tasty ideas and kitchen inspiration. Thanks for your support
